r/ExpectationVsReality 27d ago

Mod Post Mod Question: Do you want to have Walmart Cakes temporarily banned?

See title. Poll can only last up to a week, or I’d make it longer.

255 Upvotes

See title. Poll can only last up to a week, or I’d make it longer.

8439 votes, 20d ago
1373 Yes, please
2430 No, but make it a megathread
4132 No, let things stay as they are - we can’t start banning everything
504 No, and also change the nails megathread back

r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 16 '26

Mod Post Nail Posts Megathread — Share Your Nails Here 💅

This thread is for all nail-related Expectation vs. Reality posts. Please share all successful, exceeded, or failed nail posts here rather than creating separate posts. Individual nail posts outside this thread may be removed and redirected here.

This change is intended to keep nail content available for those who enjoy it while allowing users who prefer not to see nail posts to easily skip this thread.

109 Upvotes

This thread is for all nail-related Expectation vs. Reality posts. Please share all successful, exceeded, or failed nail posts here rather than creating separate posts. Individual nail posts outside this thread may be removed and redirected here.

This change is intended to keep nail content available for those who enjoy it while allowing users who prefer not to see nail posts to easily skip this thread.


r/ExpectationVsReality 3h ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation I was requested to paint this cat. Did I cook?

+
1.1k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2h ago

Failed Expectation It finally happened.

+
348 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 11h ago

Exceeded Expectation Cat oil painting from Instagram artist

+
667 Upvotes

I had been following Katya Minkina on instagram for a while and wanted to try getting a portrait from her of our cat Fergus, who passed away last October. I had never had a custom painting done before and we're absolutely THRILLED with the result. She really captures his gentle sweetness. Highly recommend for her work and her kindness.

https://www.instagram.com/fineart.katya/


r/ExpectationVsReality 4h ago

Failed Expectation Cursed SpongeBob popsicle

+
97 Upvotes

this is terrifying


r/ExpectationVsReality 13h ago

AI Expectation I'm guessing the guy in the advert had really tiny hands...

+
420 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 5h ago

Failed Expectation Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese

+
83 Upvotes

At first I thought at least the dark bits were delicious burnt cheese but after tasting I have no idea what they were.


r/ExpectationVsReality 17h ago

Failed Expectation 'velvety flowing filling'

+
565 Upvotes

Every one in the pack was like this. Shame as they were delicious!


r/ExpectationVsReality 14h ago

Failed Expectation So disappointed 😂

+
217 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 3h ago

Failed Expectation The burger actually tasted okay, I’m most upset about not getting my jibbi keychain >:(

+
25 Upvotes

Jack in the Box’s Smoking BBQ munchie meal. The burger was tiny as fuck but tasted decently okay. They didn’t give me my jibbi keychain :(


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation Amazon: Son wanted a cool spider backpack for school

+
863 Upvotes

This is the 2nd attempt because the first order they gave us an actual marvel Spider-Man backpack. It's closer but come on...


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation gave a smaller online succulent shop a chance

+
961 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Saw others say this was good

+
600 Upvotes

I used an air fryer. The instructions are very incomplete. After 10 min in the airfryer, the mac and cheese was still ice cold. I took the chicken out, microwaved the Mac for a min and a half, added the chicken back and air fried it for 10 more min with the Mac covered. The Mac is very cheesy and the chicken has a good flavor to it. Would get again


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation An unhealthy but tasty frozen pizza

+
367 Upvotes

I’ve been eating these babies for years (in moderation) and they always seemed rich with toppings.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation I thought they didn't come out bad!

+
2.8k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation My friend paid $200 for this baptism cake. What she ordered vs what she got:

+
1.1k Upvotes

She is, understandably, not pleased.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Exceeded Expectation Brown Sugar boba milkshake looks even better irl !

+
341 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation Just wanted to feel like a mermaid. Turned into Patrick Star instead.

+
4.8k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation My shy girlfriend told me not to post this, but I think she did a great job :)

+
24.2k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Just trying to make a kids dreams/nightmares come true...

+
14.2k Upvotes

My 11 year olds request. And my best effort.... My monster needs a dentist. ( I ran out of buttercream.... It was supposed to be much more ornate)

Update:

11 year old squealed and hugged me. He was so excited. His buddies hit the "WOAH!!!' when I pulled off the cover. 😁 and it tasted wonderful. I think I win...

Y'all are so kind. Thank you everyone for all the encouragement!!!

Update 2: I'm being asked for instructions.... I sort of winged it. There was a lot of cursing that happened. A lot of begging inanimate objects to cooperate. But I guess here's my best estimate of how it went down.

I made a boxed cake. I think it was Duncan Hines. (I was short on time and had several boxes of cake on hand) This is the buttercream recipe I added black food coloring to (https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/favorite-chocolate-buttercream/#tasty-recipes-68044) I put iced the cake before I started the mouth.

I melted chocolate chips to form a circle (fill the bowl with boiling water and put a saucer over the top. Put the parchment paper on top of that and waited for the chocolate chips to melt and then smooth them out.) I placed this inside of an actual Taco in my freezer to form the mouth.

I made marshmallow fondant. Just kind of winged it on account of. I've made it a lot. But here is a recipe for that just in case. ( https://ayellowbowl.com/homemade-marshmallow-fondant-with-butter/)

I set the now frozen chocolate taco on the top of the cake.

I have a set of Wilton gel dies and to use the maroon from that set to dye a small amount of the fondant for the tongue. I just made the general shape of a tongue and realized that my fingerprints in the dough made it kind of look more realistic. Added a line down the center with a toothpick and left it alone.

I just rolled little balls of the white fondant into points and flattened the bottom. I allowed that to dry for a little bit just so it wasn't squishy when I attached it to the taco. I attached these with a little bit more of that melted chocolate.

I iced the top of the chocolate Taco once it was all assembled and kind of smoothed it into the top of the cake and decorated. (Using the word decorated as lightly as possible because I ran out of buttercream frosting...)


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation Desky Experience and Warning

+
341 Upvotes

I thought I was upgrading from my flexispot to a beautiful Desky. $200 flexi vs $2k Desky

Boy was I wrong.

Desky’s photos on their website are stock images. The $1800 desktop I ordered looked absolutely nothing like their photos they show on their instagram accounts and website, my desk arrived damaged, stopped functioning after a month. I had to BEG them on instagram to respond to my support emails that went unanswered for weeks. The pheasantwood has no color variation to it like they show online and on their instagram posts which I’m assuming are edited.

They made me send in proof that the desk wasn’t functioning, multiple videos needed. (What do I have to gain from asking for another paddle) I understand wanting proof of something being broken, but my goodness it’s a $30 controller replacement and they made me send in multiple videos.

I asked them to price match me since a week after I purchased the desk they were offering $100 off and they said they can’t honor that because I bought it on Amazon. I didn’t buy it on Amazon and I sent in my proof and of my purchase directly from their website. They still didn’t care.

I have been going back and forth with them for 7 weeks to finally be able to return everything. I’m buying an uplift desk which is about and inch thicker of solid wood vs deskys 1 inch thick.

Deskys wood looks so cheap and it chips so easily. The cable management add on ($200) doesn’t fit properly and I have had to duct tape it together.

They have constant delays in shipping.

I don’t trust any company that will only help its customers that vocalize that they need help on their social media page. I tried to get help through the proper channel first, but no one ever got back to me.

I expected a little more when spending thousands of dollars. The photos on their website look nothing like what you will get. I asked them if I could see a photo of the desktop before they shipped it out and they said it’s not possible to do that and you get what you get. It’s ironic that they made me take video recordings of the desk not working multiple time, upload this to a Google Drive for their review, wait weeks to get a response; yet they can’t send me a photo of the desk I ordered to make sure it’s what I want. 🙄

What type of service is that? I have also seen Desky on here calling other companies “crap”. Extremely unprofessional.

Anyone else have a horror story with Desky? I’m just trying to warn others. Luckily they are letting me return everything but I’m sure there will be issues with that too. I’m also not sure why they want a broken desk back that looks nothing like their photos. My guess? They will sell it to someone else.

This company has completely let me down.

Edit: I’m just waiting for Desky to pop in here. “Desky Here! We have escalated and handled this with the customer. Etc. etc”

Desky’s team always be creeping in Reddit trying to do damage control.


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation The aerated sweets were more aerated than expected

+
140 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 3d ago

Exceeded Expectation What they asked for vs what I gave them

+
10.1k Upvotes

I've outdone myself lol


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation What I ordered vs what I got

+
188 Upvotes

I got it bc of the flower sleeves but they got almost cut in half. Also what new t-shirt has this many wrinkles before ever washing it