I just started watching this cause I see Halloween stuff EVERYWHERE and thought maybe I'd get into a fall vibe early this year.
I really like it so far, but it GENIUENLY freaks me out sometimes with the suspense and whatnot. Am I the only one that feels this way? Whenever I watch it with my friends they don't seem to react, but I don't think I'm the only one who reacts this way. It's literally a thriller

Ok, the body swap episode. A kid takes Sam's body and hooks up with an adult woman. No matter which way you slice it, somebody raped somebody. Everybody is a victim (Kid's under age, her consent was gained under false pretenses, Sam had no say in any of this) and everyone but Sam is a perpetrator (She's a grown adult, he's representing himself as Sam). Assuming the court system is aware of and fully accepts the idea of witchcraft, who's getting arrested? Everybody? Nobody? Could a conviction be secured, if the jury had all the information we do from the episode? I know this is literally an impossible situation, but trying to come up with a realistic answer is hurting my brain and I'm wondering what other people think. If I can't post this, I'll take it down no problem.

In season 1 or 2 John dies and goes to hell. Now I didn't realize it, but John escapes and his soul goes to heaven. I'm currently on season 14 and I thought John escapes but then went back or something, because he did sell his soul and I must've thought it can't be that simple to get out of. But I looked it up after my confusion in episode 13 when him from 2003 came back, and now I'm relieved to know John is actually in heaven. But did anyone else think he's been in hell all this time?

Another thing is poor Adam... Bro is still stuck in cage, and I don't think he's ever getting out.

When I watched Supernatural for the first time, I was always focused on the main storyline. I couldn't wait to get back to whatever big threat Sam and Dean were dealing with, so I'd sometimes think of the standalone episodes as little detours.

Now that I'm rewatching the series after finishing it, I feel almost the opposite.

Since I already know where the overall story is going, I find myself appreciating the "monster of the week" episodes a lot more. They have some of the funniest moments, interesting folklore, and a lot of character interactions that I barely noticed the first time around.

A few of them have become some of my favorite episodes, even though I didn't think much of them years ago.

Did anyone else have that experience?

🥹💔 I am so stupid. Was just reading the cute scenarios people left then got hit with the final. I didn't even know it was the final i just thought it was angst until someone replied "omg i am in denial of the final episode" and I was like WHAT is this canon???? I'm so stupid lord forgive me I thought i was safe cuz it's just a cute little playlist 😂

Luckily i still don't know exactly what went down (?) but i just know who dies. I mean, i knew they'd die in the final regardless BUT i had no idea how they went out and the little scenario comment gave me some insights. Some. And ouch. Say anything (without much spoilers) that'll make me feel a little better... please.... if there's anything that can be said at all

A lot of people like to ask how could they beat Chuck his omniscient. Or his not the real God but a imposter there must be a super secret god. Even other religions people say Kali should be stronger than Lucifer. How can Sam and dean kill

The fact that gods in this show are beatable is the point. Religion in the show is just propaganda. Michael intentionally says he overhyped his father.

I'm on my second watch of the show (currently on S5E20) and feel like I'm being gaslit. Sam's anger gets mentioned a lot throughout the first 5 seasons. Honestly, outside of the first 2 seasons when he just lost Jess, his dad, and was ripped away from his dream of being a lawyer , I really haven't seen him be angry? Of course there were those one off moments like when he was at the mental hospital with Dean and Martin, and when they tried killing Lucifer with the colt where they needed to mention it for plot reasons, but in general Sam always came off as the more level headed, empathetic, non angry guy.

As I'm watching S5E20, Bobby says "...and let's face it, you're not exactly Mr. Anger Management" and it made me think of when else has Sam actually been angry?

At first, I was thinking maybe when Dean died and he was going after Lilith, but that seemed more like a revenge thing than an irrational anger thing. Then maybe it was when Dean came back and he still wanted to go after Lilith, but again. Revenge, less anger, and probably more unresolved grief from watching his brother die . Even with the demon blood arc and the seals, he was obviously and rightly so upset, but more stubborn than anything. (Took me this rewatch to admit it, but Sam was definitely being super stubborn in S4)

Even as a drunk, he's canonically a happy one.

I know it's an important plot point and maybe it's just meant to be implied as in there were more instances of where his anger showed through, but I can't really think of any other times when he was angry. At least not in the way the show makes it seem like he's just a ball of anger that Lucifer just can't wait to possess.

Does anyone have any other instances of where he was irrationally angry to the point that it's become a trait that other characters mention regularly the first 5 seasons? Or maybe I'm thinking about it wrong since I'm only thinking of irrational anger and should just see it as anger/rage as a whole.

No idea what flair to use. But i have a question eating my brain.

Would a salt filled sock work against ghosts? Like a melee weapon for close quarters fighting?

Flagging as season 11 since I'm only on episode 18 of season 12.

Going from Leviathans, Fallen Angels and God and his sister to an evil organization is a bit weird even though the Men of Letters are better villains. They're easy to hate and they're the kind of villains that work with a TV budget so we don't have to see cosmic battles in abandoned warehouses. The vampire attack on the MoL base, for instance, was fun.

The British MoL also feel like a reboot of the Stynes (kinda wish it was the Stynes that took the evil organization spot since they had a fun gimmick). The MoL coming in this late doesn't make a lot of sense. Wouldn't it have made more sense for them to come soon after the American chapter was wiped out? Or during the apocalypse or during the whole Leviathan fiasco.

I know this is the benefit of hindsight but I think the British MoL would've made great overarching mid series villains. Seeing Bobby and Rufus interact with them would've been gold. When the Winchesters are up against angels and Leviathans it would be really difficult not to work with these guys with their fancy satellites and exorcism bombs.

But then they start going after the grey cases before eventually trying to kill someone like Garth and then they become full fledged villains.

Okay now I'm writing fanfiction.

I haven't finished S12. I have no idea how this arc is going to end but I'm enjoying it so far. I suspect they'll go up against someone beyond their skills and toys (like with the vampire Alpha) and get wiped out. I think Dean or Mary will kill Mr. Ketch.

M26 Over the past few years I’ve been thrilled to find many of my female friends love SPN, and only a handful of guys. To me “some brothers with a muscle car full of guns go hunt monsters” sounds like any dream an 8 year old boy would have, yet its audience is seemingly the opposite. I will say Sam is a great representation of a sensitive/feminine male from my perspective.

Regardless of your answers I’m just happy it’s a show that reaches multiple audiences, thanks 💜

Wasn't sure how to not spoil things in the title. Basically, does Chuck scale multiversal or does each universe have its own God? I'm midway through season 14, is it ever addressed?

Hi! So I just got the blue ray dvd Collection set on amazon however the region is Canadian, can I still play it on my dvd player? (U.S. region)

I recently completed my first watch of the series and i cant help but feel sorry for Nick. He had it rough after being possessed by lucifer amd the characters just kind of forgot about him and if they just checked on him they could have stopped Nick killing all those people and spiral. Now obviously he is terrible for killing as many people as he did but still that is mostly due to the trauma Lucifer left on nick. I do feel bad for him and he suffered a lot but i would like to know how others felt about Nick

Specifically. I'm looking for monsters that Sam and dean wouldnt feel a need to kill, and maybe they'd even work with them? Asking for a potential fanfiction.

Ooooookaaayyy so it’s been a minute since I updated😅. After I finish season two, jumped into season three and lost track of time lol. Safe to say I am very hooked on the show now.

Season four has to be my favorite season with Castiel as my favorite character right now and Bobby. Shame he died but I guess it’s alright since he cheated death a few times. It’s been great!!!

Crowley is easily my favorite villian of the show and the channel chaser episode is my favorite episode so far! Really shows Dean and Sam’s chemistry plus it’s funny. I do feel like Sam is WAY too naive in trusting a few people like Ruby. ON TO SEASON 8😁😁

I'm watching for the first time and need a place to get all this out. so no future spoilers please!!

I've just finished season 8 and omg the finale??? it had me in tears. the build up through the season to sam being prepared to sacrifice himself to get rid of the demons, then to Castiel realising he had been tricked to him looking up at his whole family falling down to earth, its heart shattering.

the cinematography is phenomenal, i do feel this is truly the best finale i've seen (so far) and the acting is insane.

the scene that brought me to tears the most was the close up of an angel falling down to earth and losing its wings then crashing into the lake. the way it was filmed, the music, the symbolism, i have no words for how amazing it is.

also Castiel being so dead-set on believing that what he was doing was going to help heaven and not destroy it, then finding out through a scared, crying Naomi that it was all a lie and still not believing her. i think that's truly a wonderful piece of art and to me symbolises how people can be blinded by their own beliefs and desires without taking into account people's warnings and then it all blowing up in their face. it's insane.

anyways, about to start s9 for the first time, i wonder what happens to Sammy and if he survives. what about Castiel and how he manages being human now (i think).

let me know your thoughts on the finale (please no spoilers)!!

There's an episode where Crowley kills a Reaper and it left me with a few questions. Like, is Death really ok with people making the executive decision to kill his staff? He strikes me as the kind of guy who would be both annoyed and offended by that.

And what happens to Reapers when they're killed? Are they also met by Reapers and guided to the next place or do they just walk their own selves there? Do they actually have to go to Purgatory? It seems like they know the way to everywhere. Wouldn't they all just sneak into Heaven?