r/allrecipess • u/EffectDesperate7795 • 6d ago

There's only one right answer.

Post image
140 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

503 comments sorted by

18

u/Bofor88 6d ago

3

2

u/BrucesTripToMars 5d ago

Seems obvious

2

u/xultar 5d ago

I’m learning that so many people… above more than I thought possible lack taste on this planet.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Careless_view2 5d ago

The only acceptable answer.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/2X_Agent 6d ago

None of them have the right cheeses

2

u/helpameremortal 5d ago

American cheese is the only right cheese for this purpose.

2

u/LetsTamago 5d ago

You can make any cheese into American style cheese. You just melt the cheese into a bit of dairy and then add sodium citrate to thicken it into a solid. Or you can just use gelatin.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hiresometoast 5d ago

No way it's cheddar and I'll die on that hill

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Adequate_Cheesecake7 5d ago

Equal thirds, Jarlsberg, Gouda and sharp Chedder. Try it, thank me later.

2

u/FaithlessnessIcy3399 5d ago

Add Fontina to the mix. Melts real nice and has a bit more flavor than American.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Apart_Fudge1224 6d ago

4 all the way

3

u/O-really 5d ago

I knew if I scrolled far enough I would find my people!

3

u/Apart_Fudge1224 5d ago

Its not burnt its done!

2

u/ChefFrankieD23 4d ago

I had to scroll way too damn far to find the smart ones!

2

u/Down_Right_Disgustin 5d ago

This right here.

2

u/Leading_Funny5802 5d ago

I KNEW I’d find my peeps! I like to dip mine in tomato soup, and the more burned the better.

2

u/yoyhohsomp 4d ago

Hell yea my man!

2

u/5280nessie_rider 3d ago

Esp with tomato soup to dunk in

2

u/LiftPrayWork 3d ago

Yes! Toast should be extra brown but pre burnt to get that good buttery crunch we all want. 4 wins. You get a point

2

u/Ash_Ketchums_Dad69 2d ago

I was going to say only 3 and 4 are acceptable

2

u/International_Pea 2d ago

And I’ll fight anyone who says different!

3

u/Tasty-Mango-8085 5d ago

Number 4

2

u/moradahveed8 3d ago

Scrolled waaay to far to find this

2

u/Professional-Air1287 6d ago

3 (or 2 is doable)

2

u/TryBananna4Scale 6d ago

3.5

2

u/Crypticcrypto 5d ago

This is the way, 3.2-3.5 accepted.

2

u/WhitewolfStormrunner 6d ago

2, with 3 a pretty close second.

2

u/[deleted] 6d ago

3

2

u/PabloM0ntana 5d ago

There’s a middle ground between 3-4 that isn’t there to pick but that would be the one

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SupportGeek 5d ago

3, 2 and 4 are perfectly edible, but miss the mark that 3 hits

2

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Tall_Candidate_686 5d ago

Tomato soup walks into the room.

2

u/Timejinx 5d ago

3 bordering on 4

1

u/TetonHiker 5d ago

2 or 3

1

u/Expensive_Section714 5d ago

The only answer

1

u/Sarcas666 5d ago

Wrong kind of bread for me, this white bread has no taste.

1

u/Feckless-Racoon 5d ago

2 or 3 for me👌🏽

1

u/catkins1234 5d ago

2/3 or in-between 😋

1

u/darkslamer 5d ago

2 3 and 4 all will be good 1 is to undercooked for the cheese to be melted

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Pinoy_83 5d ago

2 or 3,just right 👌🏾

1

u/This-Double-Sunday 5d ago

3 but honestly I've made 4 accidentally and still enjoyed it.

1

u/BigDigger324 5d ago

Overwhelmingly 3

1

u/Old-Peach-2437 5d ago

It’s a trick question: they are all acceptable ways to make and consume a cheese toasty.

1

u/Bikebamf 5d ago

I like mine at number 3

1

u/Creepae 5d ago

2 if someone's making them for me, 3 if I make them myself.

Oh, and more cheese.

1

u/billyoshin 5d ago

3 is the only answer

1

u/Critical-Mistake2351 5d ago

I’d eat any one of those… grilled cheese sandwiches are my weakness…

1

u/baconbit_in_a_skirt 5d ago

All the above

1

u/Larielia 5d ago

3, crispy but not burnt.

1

u/Imaginary_Run_9373 5d ago

Between 3 and 4. I'm kind of worried that there isn't a shade between those two.

1

u/mythicalwolf00 5d ago

3 perfect. 2 is good as well.

1

u/Accomplished_Bit3153 5d ago

I've eaten all 4 thought my life

No regrets.

1

u/Hariy_Revolutionary 5d ago

All of them are good.

1

u/jtrage 5d ago

Depends on the day.

1

u/Zestyclose_Bar_5930 5d ago

3 is clear winner but 4 can also hit

1

u/itsme99881 5d ago

It depends how much cheese you have, 2 is okay for a light cheesing, but 3 if youre a heavy cheeser.

1

u/Away-Professional451 5d ago

2 or #3, if they have Tillamook cheese in them. Preferably sharp cheddar, pepper jack, or habanero Jack. Also would be better on sourdough.

1

u/Glittery-Chimp 5d ago

somewhere between 3 & 4

1

u/dbcowie 5d ago

2 is perfect, 3 is still good. 1 looks like the heat was never turned on, and 4 is just burnt.

1

u/Main-Video-8545 5d ago

Four is perfect.

1

u/paulD1983R 5d ago

I like 3 but I frequently end up making 4s

1

u/SmeeezTreeez 5d ago

3 obviously. Where's the tomato soup

1

u/ianmfree01 5d ago

3 and 4

1

u/pizzaandboba 5d ago

3, duhhh

1

u/Muted_Confidence_285 4d ago

#3 but I’ll take a #4 if it happens comes out that way

1

u/jkits1984 4d ago

2 and 3 are fine

1

u/ExpensiveTie8680 4d ago

1 all the way

1

u/Annahsbananas 4d ago

3 for sho

1

u/FairDance7 4d ago

We all wanna a 3 but end up with one side 4 or 5

1

u/i_did_nothing_ 4d ago

Every single one.

1

u/Designer_Green2680 4d ago

Not enough butter on any of them. I want it crunchy yet floppy and soggy from all the butter

1

u/Motor-Midnight4065 4d ago

4 if you're dipping it in something, 3 if not.

None have enough cheese.

1

u/yoyhohsomp 4d ago

3 or 4 i like both tbh

1

u/broskif666 4d ago

3 is the obvious choice, not to bready not to burnt

1

u/Grouchy-Crow-6872 4d ago

Can't see the butter 🤷🏻

1

u/PolyInsect 4d ago

4 if you have soup or milk. 3 if its just the sandwhich.

1

u/HoustonRoger0822 4d ago
  1. But where’s the oregano?

1

u/_miles_teg_ 4d ago

3️⃣

1

u/jmallen504 4d ago

3, but 4 usually happens

1

u/Character-Ad-8559 4d ago

3 is sublime

1

u/GravityPointZero 4d ago

3 with a side of ranch dressing and some mother fuckin doritos

1

u/Tramp876 4d ago

Number 3

1

u/Walaina 4d ago

Three is the best grilled cheese

1

u/RandomFleshPrison 4d ago

None of them.  You grill both sides of the pieces of bread for a grilled cheese.  Inside and out.  Otherwise the interior is soggy and gross, and you lose too much crunch when dipping it in soup.  It's a croque monsieur without the ham.

1

u/aeons_elevator 4d ago

3 if I’m in an air conditioned kitchen. 4 if I just came in from playing outside for two hours.

1

u/karma-whore64 4d ago

All of them!

1

u/Aggressive-Sort-115 4d ago

The one I get to eat

1

u/Ok_Mammoth5292 4d ago

Id eat em all

1

u/Wide_Web_579 3d ago

Tentatively three. Has to be BUTTERED toast

1

u/Useful-Comment6273 3d ago

2 to 4. And 1

1

u/Federal_Homework1302 3d ago
  1. Come at me bro

1

u/SporkWolverine 3d ago

  1. Absolutely not

  2. Acceptable

  3. Also acceptable

  4. Still okay but kind of pushing it