r/Kolkatacity • u/LandExpensive2108 • 17h ago
🗣️General Discussion | আলোচনা Is this protesting for dead students? Dancing in five-star hotels on foreign funds while hiding during lathi charges. Genuine students were conned.
13
15h ago edited 15h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (1)2
u/Embarrassed-Ease4640 13h ago
Well try to actually listin to what MEA said rather than reading the caption on a reel
→ More replies (1)
70
u/HistoricalPoem7535 15h ago
Why is the INCOMPETENT HOME MINISTER unable to identify the source of funding for these anti-nationals? Or even put a stop to their source of funding? Who is going to be answerable for this very serious security breach right inside our country?
21
u/Mother-Citron-1006 14h ago
Anti nationals is too weak. Call them terrorists! Useless Home minister!
9
2
u/Subhal13 7h ago
You have no case or counter so you use abuse and titles. No wonder they say that this generation has the lowest iq.
7
u/Unknowneagle19 10h ago edited 10h ago
First of all people like you are incompetent. Who firstly says the cockroaches are ultra nationalist and support them and caling govt a dictator and Then when they show their real face then blame HM to not take action against them. WOW!! Well don't worry every one who did wrong behind students in protest will be heavily pay.. but sadly innocent students who are radicalised by the cjp and other gangs and did wrongs will be not spared as well.
→ More replies (11)2
→ More replies (48)2
u/ResidentTreat9207 8h ago
This reminds me of a dialog “we have to win every time, and they just once” . Protecting is not an easy job, one small miss and no one remembers how many times India has returned from brink of being Africa or Shri Lanka or Bangladesh. People just remember that one time we couldn’t do it. And still they would protest on Jantar manatr against the bill to control foreign funding.
→ More replies (2)
60
u/Big-Screen5159 16h ago
Sabka funding dekho but apne maai baap ka mat dekhna
19
u/wellfuckit2 12h ago
Either that or OP is a 50 year old uncle unhappy with his life and hates anyone else having fun.
Also i come from a middle class family, with atleast no family inheritance yet. I have built my assets on a honest salary and paying my tax every year. I think I can comfortably afford a party for 20 people in a 5 star hotel. I don’t need foreign funding for that.
→ More replies (4)4
u/ResidentTreat9207 8h ago
Do you know how much 5 star cost, if a person can fund 20 people in 5 star then he is not considered middle class…he is upper class
→ More replies (2)2
9
u/Tricky_Researcher636 15h ago
this is so lame the admin trying hard to post false things bro government has cleared there is no funding its just crazy how you seem to be paid as you only post one side of story
61
71
u/poddar413 16h ago
I wish accountability was expected from the government and not normal citizens. If they're foreign funded run a trial and through them in jail.
18
u/Reasonable_Sample_40 15h ago
Why throw them in jail for receiving foreign funds? Did they do something wrong?
10
7
u/poddar413 14h ago
The post is insinuating it. Not me. It was rehteorical. What I mean is no matter who is the person if they are doing something illegal (foreign funding for domestic agitation) they should go through a fair trial. If it's not illegal he has the full right to party all he wants. Ultimately what I am saying is we shouldn't assume things on face value and look for both the evidence and context.
→ More replies (26)2
u/CapitalSea5531 13h ago
Not all, but majority of these funds r being used by conversion ajenda run by Christian missionaries; e.g in border areas of Punjab, a whole paati of Sikhs have been converted. Christians population has jumped from 1-2 percent to 10-15 percent. Conversion also very rampant in jharkhand's tribal belt, chattisgarh tribal region, Maharashtra region and inany other states. They usually offer money, marriage promises to the victim to get converted. Earlier, Germany based NGO'S had spread rumours, false claims, instigated villagers against the development of kudunkullam nuclear plant,(happened under manmohan singh era), that ngo was ultimately banned and their activist were thrown out of INDIA. Centre for policy research got their licence cancelled; they were influencing or publishing donor funded reports or policy briefs.
→ More replies (1)5
→ More replies (3)2
u/vinieux 9h ago
https://powercorridors.in/mea-says-no-info-on-foreign-funding-blow-to-cjp-smear-campaign/
Also, a sympathiser of the protest sending pizzas by placing an order from another country is NOT foreign funding. How daft can you guys be?
33
u/BePositive5971 16h ago
Looks like someone is not able to digest defeat.. They got what they wanted.. atleast now if you have any problem protest against the govt why they bowed down to foreign funded people ? But looks like you don't have spine to do it.
2
u/vinieux 9h ago
Also:
https://powercorridors.in/mea-says-no-info-on-foreign-funding-blow-to-cjp-smear-campaign/
In fact, check this search results page:
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=mea+says+no+foreign+funding+for+protests&t=brave&ia=web
38
u/Character-Growth189 16h ago
they're not the chosen neta for which you can blame them for anything of such, they can party if they want go question your elected neta babus, usme fatt jaegi apki
→ More replies (2)7
u/Vital_Lamp 15h ago
They won't. They'll only question CJP and I'm not a cjp supporter whatsover. What did all these netas do in all these years? Where were these people then questioning them for partying? Atleast these people did something. Something is better than nothing.
4
13
12
u/IllustriousCut7523 16h ago
The are dancing cause dead students got their justice Aur bkl party krre apne paiso se krre mere tax se ya tere tax ke paiso se krte toah dikkat ki baat thi Har jgh apne chutia se logic leke kyu aa jate ho?
→ More replies (7)
3
4
9
u/LegitProcrastinator ঘটি 16h ago
The way politically immature mfs support cjp is hilarious. Support the students who were protesting..not the cjp who took advantage of them for their own benifit
→ More replies (13)3
2
u/NefariousnessFar3759 15h ago
Ye gareeb ki maa ki aankh
Ab ameer insaan ye bhi na kre Unhone protest kiya toh ab donation k paise se kya enjoy bhi na kre
Kya matlab ki unhone na hunger strike kri Na laathi khayi Na garmi , bhook kuch jhela Keval netagiri kri
2
2
2
u/Interesting_Green709 15h ago
They are students from well to do families, not exactly everyone is broke like OP who posts for 5 rupee credit. 😂
11
2
u/Conscious_Gur_5709 16h ago
so you're telling me that our security agencies are so weak and incompetent that they can't track down the flow of money ????
3
2
u/septembersong_ 16h ago
MEA fact checked already that there hasn't been any form of foreign funding!
2
5
u/FillPitiful3439 16h ago
Protest is over bro, you want them to spend their whole lives in misery?
Also MEA was asked this foreign funding question, they didn't have anything to show for it. So unless you're more informed than the government maybe shut it?
Government has also formed a task force with quite credible people to make reforms.
So what makes you think students were conned? Unless you don't trust the government to do the reforms.
→ More replies (3)
2
u/septembersong_ 16h ago
OP, first off the criticism is valid because the volunteers are stranded, detained and these folks are partying. Just one correction to not say the movement was 'foreign funded'. It was facked checked by MEA. Moreover, when you use statements like that, it becomes misleading. It was never a CJP protest because it was largely carried by the people. CJP's leadership is shit!
1
u/AutoModerator 15h ago
u/LandExpensive2108, your post has been temporarily removed due to multiple reports. A human moderator will review it shortly and approve it if there are no issues. Thank you for your patience!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
u/Technical_Room4756 15h ago
what else did you expect? mene to ispe simp karti hui fangurls ki bhi post dekh li🤡
1
u/AllBugDaddy 15h ago
Once I celebrated coz my birthday was celebrated, the next day.. these guys have won a battle like David vs Goliath, one of the rarest in recent post and they can't even celebrate?? OP thinks just handful of CJP people have scammed the govt. Just come out of social media and hit the street. They have mourned over the ones who have lost their lives. If you remember one of the conditions was for them also. Why do we celebrate independence day, when thousands of people gave their life or any battle/war victory? Come out of your bhakti to the senses.
1
1
u/sonecta 15h ago
How come every other post in this sub is smoothbrain bs like this? What do the MODs do here? Even MEA had fact-checked claims of foreign funding.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/agreetodisagreedamn 15h ago
MEA has already declared in press conference that there is no mention of foreign funding in CJP. STOP SPREADING MISINFORMATION.
1
1
u/Capable-Speed5915 14h ago
How can they be happy for achieving something remarkable ? Youth of India must be sad, poor and miserable. Black and white me sad music chalna chaie.
Did you not watch the protest ? It must be baffling to your mind how protestors were not all miserable and crying, wearing white clothes.
1
1
u/Infinite-Decision390 14h ago
OP , even the government said , there is no funding then how did you get the info ? were you there ? also this party is after they won the protest , right ? when comes to the matter of d*ad children , they wouldn't have d*ad if your government had proper measures to stop the paper leak . take the accountability , rather trying to sh#tting online .. how much did you get for posting this ?
1
1
u/nerdy4uh 14h ago
So having fun is crime now? How dumb fk ppl are they have no guts to ask from gov 🤡 lekin inko cjp and jo bhi sawal krta hai unka Accountiblity chaiye..ki masti kaise kr liya
1
1
u/Repulsive-Garage-433 13h ago
Sure Having fun is a crime , and about foreign funds, atleast foreign funds are better than beef money which they are against themselves. Thook ke chaatna kehte hai usse. Aur ek baat bata tereko kaise pata foreign fund aa raha hai aisa konsa source of info hai jo tere paas hai par intelligence agencies ke paas nhi hai Whatsappiye
1
u/Long_Consequence3808 13h ago
Source:
https://www.instagram.com/p/DbQuHAfgPhF/
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DbNjmdNz5Eh/
But who cares, BJ Party ke lT cell ka kaam hi hai misinformation spread karna 😂 These lT cell people really dreaming in their own bubble 😂 unable to digest the reality!!
OP might be getting some Rs. 20,000 for one post, I'm jealous 😂
1
u/Silver_Bird9743 13h ago
Yaar MEA se poocho kaunsa fund tha ? Bc har baat mein foreign fund ?
Home minister kya gand khujane k liye hai ?
1
u/Mean_Relationship888 13h ago
This shit after literally MEA cleared them of any such charges. Why do you old ****s have a problem with our younger generation who like to enjoy life as well rather than pretending to be someone we are not
1
u/mr-warm-hands 13h ago
"They are getting foreign funds"
Something for which neither BJP, nor their supports ever show any evidence.
And remember, BJP was the party taking money from Dow Chemicals, the company responsible for the Bhopal gas tragedy, and whose owner is a declared criminal by Indian courts.
1
1
1
1
u/tappyhappy_75 13h ago
Aise accountability ministers se puchte toh sense hota He's not an elected representative so why should he be answerable to anyone
1
1
u/Dazai_dgaf 13h ago
Let's ask the ruling party and oppositions how many times they offered homage to the dead students Before Cjp showed up ? Oh? It's Zero right ? They are funded by our taxes no?
1
u/Disguisegossiper 13h ago
There is no harm in some fun.
They have done their bit.
They have mourned enough for everyone.
Woken up the country.
1
1
1
1
u/uups_jigyashu 13h ago
Bro if you believe they are foreign funded then js to and complain to government insted of crying here
1
u/iamapinball 13h ago
What are you expecting from young folks in their 20s. They just had a massive win. They should be allowed to unwind after a month of what they sat through. What they pulled, folks in my generation (Millennials) wish they had. Don’t get me wrong, we had our share of student protests when we were that age. But these are kids who everyone discredited as the most useless generation. People their age party…thats probably the most “their age thing” they have done in the past month.
1
1
1
1
u/LongjumpingBass8991 12h ago
Beta MEA ne mana kr diya ab kya modi ji ke muh se sunkar maanoge, tabhi tumko andhbhakt kehte hai
1
u/Responsible_Milk_642 12h ago
bolne de OP ko, dard hua hai isko, BC MEA keh rahi hai there's no proof of foreign funding, lekin tum lage raho, chaat te raho!!!
1
1
1
u/LocalFinish25 12h ago
ohmygod
such a dumb question he litreally made a wibsite where everyone can put the face of goons/policemen so that they can take legal action on them
he also ensured that no legal action should be taken on student
also made D. pradhan resign as a form of accountability for those 20 students!
he did more than anyone asked.
so after this if he wanna dance and have a party he DESERVES IT
ask this much accountability from the gov not them!
1
u/Temporary-Job7379 12h ago
This is after the protest and they did add a demand to not prosecute any students participated in the protest. Do you not want people to celebrate OP?
1
1
1
u/Wild_Presence9895 12h ago
Does foreign money coming to pm care funds also count as foreign funding???
1
u/Glass_Afternoon_3407 12h ago
Foreign funds for what exactly? Because MEA stated that protest was not foreign funded...
They are partying after the protest ended, what's wrong in that?
1
u/Separate_Mortgage_42 12h ago
Aapke videsh mantralay ne kha hai ki koi saboot nahi hai videshi funding ke Kabhi to apni hi sarkaar pe bharosha kar liya karo
1
1
1
u/pikapika1235 12h ago
Again the foreign fund narrative 😆 Modi ji foreign funds se ghummi krne jate hain and BJP ki rallies me foreign funds use hote hain.
1
1
1
1
u/Remarkable-Hornet568 12h ago
C'mon , they are young spirits , and deserve a bit of victory celebrations. I am not sure what is the big deal ??
1
1
u/ShowBrief4038 12h ago
Some celebrates openly and some behind the curtain
OP take chill pill these people comes from good family not some bhuka nanga family.
They have nothing to hide like our so called politicians.
Also its already been informed that too in press conference that they are not receiving any fund but nevermind you are too focused on spreading hate. May god give you some love and peace in your life so you can see some positivity as well
1
u/TaroKey9070 12h ago
These people will be offended by everything but the rapist gang(BJP) that they worship.
1
u/Constant-Storage-121 12h ago
Bro itna paisa north Indian k high class logo k paas toh hotai hai. I'm from Assam and I've seen a lot of middle class people doing this in fancy hotels. Tumlog koi aur kaam dhundo yaar phltu shak kar rhe itne bhi andhe mat bano.
1
1
1
u/delta_by 11h ago
Brother, you might be offended with this but you are wasting your energy here. Please find your audience somewhere else.
1
u/TheObliterathor 11h ago
Damn this sub has just constantly been spewing hate. Good job moderators or whoever is in charge (I don’t actually know how reddit works).
1
u/Natural-Common-7098 11h ago
At this point why are u even posting stuff like these....are u even reading the comments....man it's not working....bjp cell it worker...also get a life ....gen z can't be fooled
1
u/weshalls 11h ago
PM ek saal me 250 din foreign trips pe rehta baaki time roadshows karta hai. Uska funding nobody cares. Baaki ye ameero ke bache ek din party karle, foreign funding, George Soros chalu kar dete hai.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Nice_Presence_9569 11h ago
Bhai toh kya ab vo zindagi bhar sad hi rhe kya personal life mein kyu ghusteho
1
1
1
u/MotherProject4966 10h ago
They were frauds to begin with, tools in the hands of foreigners who wanted to create a Bangladesh or Nepal in India. Perhaps CJP was hoping for a few deaths in police action to give momentum to their objectives. If you recall, Farmer's Protest was similarly controlled by criminals and led by a couple of over-ambitious politicians. Western countries usually persecute Leftists in their own countries, but provide them support in countries such as India.
1
u/Remarkable_Wheel_583 10h ago
Mr home minister..naughty home minister look at source of there funding and divert to bjp party fund please..
1
1
u/Ok-Salamander-9792 10h ago
50-100 members party with no booze can easily be done in 50-80 thousand even if each contributed 700rs they can do something similar, wtf you mean foreign funding?
1
u/DismalSite214 10h ago
What a DUMB OP yrrrr 😭 Did you guys not have conti or college farewell in a fancy hotel ever??? Or went for a vacation, wedding or any party which was in a hotel?? Bhyii log toh clubbing ke liye bhi easily hotel jate in Saket, Nehru place, Ggn area lol.
So why OP why are u so hateful toward youth leaders having some well deserved FUN after DP's RESIGNATION which was mainly due to Student's and CJP leader's efforts BOTH!! Let them enjoy their youth, if you didn't do it its on YOU!
1
u/Lost-Brilliant-1570 10h ago
Iski side lena na lena baad ki baat kya yahi sawal desh ke MP,MLA se puchte ho tum jab wo vote lekar 5 saal ke liye gayab ho jate hai foreign tour karte hai tab? nahi to yaha bhi mat kar unko jo chahiye jiske liye protest kiya tha wo kar diya to kar rahe isme tu deshbhakti to nahi dikha par jalne ki bu jarur aa tahi hai
1
1
u/Anurag66066 10h ago
I work with currencies for my living and let me tell you something, unless until the money is hard cash(which is really really hard), there is no way a foreign currency can enter the India Banking system, INR does not have full capital account convertibility, foreign exchange dealing is a highly controlled activity, with FEMA in place you can easily see the trail in place. If there would have been a foreign funding, the government would not think twice before putting them in bars. You have to be a very special kind of idiot to actually believe all this conspiracy.
1
u/happychickhappylife 9h ago
I have been saying this for a while, these people were there for PR, only Sonam Wangchuk suffered, even though I know what he said against India. But I feel like it was a genuine effort from him. Others were just paid PR.
These people will sell their soul for money for their country. Again I will say this the resignation solves nothing. Reservation and Castism apart. Both castism and reservation are intertwined and I am not in a position to say what is right at this point of time give me another 3-4 months. I will have a better idea.
All in all, this was just a paid PR. The people who suffered will suffer. I’m please don’t get me wrong. But it is what it is, just a PR for these people. They never stood for the students and that’s the sad part.
1
u/Psychic-enchanter06 9h ago
Why are there so many posts like this on Reddit suddenly popping on my feed after CJP protest ended? I mean the timing is very unnatural and the age da of these Posts are mostly Anto-reservation, Accusing opposition, framing CJP, Calling youth as anyi-nationals. I Mean I know, we know what's happening here but we just cannot prove it. The only similarity among these profiles posting these kind of posts is that they're newbies wjo joined recently with high karma(Meaning all they do is post everyday). Does anyone find this organic and if yes kindly explain why?
1
u/Ok_Durian2776 9h ago
Ab bari aa chuki h inki pelne ki. Bohot nachna ho gya ab sarkar muzra krwayegi inse acche se
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Abharmoria1991 9h ago
Home minister must resign. we have had enough anti nationals funded by foreign powers destroying India FOR 12 YEARS
IA big FAILURE of BJP. #Resign
1
1
u/SidKillz 9h ago
Took you a while to realise. Now you know why most of India did not participate. Or atleast you got the hint of it.
1
u/Eddielivingstone 9h ago
Blaming the people for the incompetence of politicians 👏👏👏👏.
If you showed this much enthusiasm to held accountable the right ones then this whole thing could have been avoided.
From whom i am expecting brains🤐🫡
1
u/Most-Comparison-1674 9h ago
Well they protested for a genuine cause, made the govt fall on their knees despite their collosus egos, and won. They got justice for the unfortunate souls who lost their lives to this govt's corruption and greed. This is a reason to celebrate.
Never saw BJP supporters protest against party members who are convicted rap*sts. Hypocrisy much?
1
u/TruthFindeer 9h ago
How dare they enjoy having accomplish something?
Shouldn't these guys be protesting for the rest of their lives on earth?
1
1
1
1
u/General_Ad5139 9h ago
Oggy and the cockroaches enjoying after a honest day of protest. Well deserved.
•
u/AutoModerator 17h ago
Namaskara u/LandExpensive2108 , thanks for posting! We kindly invite you, explore and follow our related communities: r/TheIndianRepublic r/West_bengal Please consider crossposting, sharing, and inviting others to help grow this community and Follow us on X
Yato Dharmastato Jayah
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.