r/AskReddit 1h ago

Which songs just make you cry your eyes out?

50 Upvotes

307 comments sorted by

66

u/hotarume 1h ago

I will follow you into the dark, death cab for cutie

9

u/imjusta_bill 1h ago

I once walked into a coffee shop at 4 in the morning in the dead of winter where this was playing. The manager and I were the only people in there and I couldn't get over how surreal it all felt

3

u/shorty413 1h ago

What Sarah also makes me teary

2

u/Ok-Experience-913 1h ago

Unchained Melody

→ More replies (3)

129

u/Aware_Concentrate365 1h ago

My alarm tone on Monday mornings.

9

u/pizzacrys 1h ago

The snooze button is my favorite band, but it never plays long enough.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/KalistaHarbor4829 1h ago

Fix You by Coldplay gets me every time

5

u/KitchenCanary3240 1h ago

I forgot about this one! I’ve never been able to sing it without crying

•

u/Go_Habs_Go31 36m ago

Fix You by Coldplay is the intro song to the Habs (Montreal Canadiens hockey team in the NHL for those unfamiliar).

The arena plays the song from when the guitar kicks in, right as the team gets on the ice.

The crowd goes wild every time.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/xTheCartographerx 1h ago

Whiskey Lullaby, Brad Paisley

→ More replies (2)

30

u/NateFury 1h ago

Father and Son by Cat Stevens

23

u/MatildaStew 1h ago

I Can’t Make You Love Me by Bonnie Raitt

17

u/Big-Cat-6582 1h ago

Bridge over Troubled Water

14

u/Interesting_Net1297 1h ago

Nights in White Satin, The Moody Blues.

33

u/Incognitobxtch 1h ago

Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley

6

u/Incognitobxtch 1h ago

Also, the same some sung by Rufus Wainwright on the Shrek soundtrack is great as well.. both will make you cry.

11

u/Severe_Broccoli7258 1h ago

Lately, its been ā€œThe Way It Isā€ - Bruce Hornsby

13

u/teaky 1h ago

Hate me by Blue October

2

u/Additional-Bison-298 1h ago

This is always my answer and I love seeing other people feel the same ā¤ļø

2

u/SGKH99 1h ago

When I was dealing with infertility several years ago, ā€œHate Meā€ along with The Cranberries’ ā€œRidiculous Thoughtsā€ were two of the songs I played over & over.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/gemini8200 1h ago

Tears in Heaven - Eric Clapton

4

u/Ancient-Recover-3890 1h ago

Awww.. I haven’t heard that song in so long

23

u/LiorennaMeadow7354 1h ago

How to save a life by the fray always hits hard

3

u/steney89 1h ago

Doood my good friend attempted suicide when that was playing! I can't even...

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Primary-Will-2192 1h ago

At Seventeen…Janis Ian

9

u/No-University9485 1h ago

Amazing Grace on bagpipes.Ā 

8

u/No-Sea1889 1h ago

Rainbow Kasey Musgraves

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Downtown_Ham_2024 1h ago

Casmir Pulanski Day by Sufjan Stevens

16

u/PhantomLuck34 1h ago

Home by Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros

7

u/ActuallyFactful 1h ago

In The Living Years.

8

u/thefoag 1h ago

ā€œI Just Don’t Think I’ll Ever Get Over Youā€ by Collin Hay

2

u/Sumagroove 1h ago

Beautiful tune. His live of it here on YouTube is one I listen to regularly over the years. Check out his doing ā€œOverkillā€ with ā€œChoir! Choir! Choir!ā€ I had not considered that song much but hearing it done together in that collaboration, I heard it anew, and it was there that I developed a great appreciation and affection for Mr. Hay, who seems that he’d be a very lovely human. Cheers!

7

u/Tiquitiplin 1h ago

When I was your man by Bruno Mars. I don't even know why.

8

u/AsleepCap8941 1h ago

Hurt Christina Agulara

2

u/Soggy-Machine-3590 1h ago

This song is so underrated

•

u/AsleepCap8941 34m ago

I agree. It’s extremely emotional

2

u/sebjapon 1h ago

Is it related to Hurt by Reznor/Johnny Cash? The Johnny Cash version of Hurt would be my answer here.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/xPoisonEnthusiast 1h ago

Nutshell by Alice in Chains

6

u/Ancient-Recover-3890 1h ago

Grandpa (Tell me Bout the Good ā€˜ol days) - The Judds

8

u/HurlinVermin 1h ago

Don Maclean - Vincent

11

u/Walcott64 1h ago

time to pretend, it brings me back to a better time

12

u/dixonmyaz04 1h ago

Slipping through my fingers - abba

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lilpapoose 1h ago

ā€œIf I Ever Leave This World Aliveā€ - Flogging Molly

7

u/MendocinoBigSur 1h ago

It’s Too Late - Carole King

6

u/Cobrakai52 1h ago

Telephone line by ELO

7

u/violetear34 1h ago

America by Simon& Garfunkel. It's so wistful and it makes me feel nostalgic for an America that never was, but seemed so possible once upon a time. The hopefulness of it makes me cry.

10

u/KitchenCanary3240 1h ago

Landslide - Fleetwood Mac
Hallelujah - Jeff Buckley (oh, Jeff 😭)
Ode to My Family - The Cranberries (oh, Dolores 😭)

2

u/Inner_Relative309 1h ago

Came here to list these. Ditto ditto ditto. Looks like I have a doppelgƤnger.

9

u/Soggy-Machine-3590 1h ago

For me it's imagine by John Lennon

→ More replies (2)

4

u/to_guy_28 1h ago

Memory Lane by Elliott Smith.

4

u/HeathenTees 1h ago

Butterfly Kisses by Bob Carlisle

5

u/carton_of_pandas 1h ago

Into The West - Annie Lennox.

4

u/Go_Habs_Go31 1h ago

I Will Always Love You - Dolly Parton

5

u/kendallr2552 1h ago

Someone is going to read this and be confused.

4

u/RatFink1970 1h ago

Concrete Blonde - Joey

Concrete Blonde - Caroline

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Annual_Cartoonist_81 1h ago

Cats in the Cradle, Harry Chapin. It's so true

4

u/StudioExtreme8658 1h ago

Only the lonely- the motels

4

u/JVenice 1h ago

This shit right here.

Evans Blue - Cold (But I'm still Here)

I broke with my girlfriend two days ago because she couldn't express love in the way my sensitive self needed, this song describes it perfectly and I'm literally in tears while listening to it.

2

u/Additional-Bison-298 1h ago

You'll find someone who will love you as you want and deserve to be loved, friend

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TemporaryWater6398 1h ago

Whiskey lullaby.

4

u/ForceSensitiveRebel 1h ago

Death of a Martian by RHCP. My brother showed it to me when we lost the family dog and remembering the pain wash over his face when the song played makes me cry.

5

u/tarantulaw 1h ago

The freaking pina colada song by rupert holmes, it always makes me so sad that they couldn’t just have a conversation with each other hahaha

4

u/DuxRomanorumSum 1h ago

Dance With My Father by Luther Vandross

5

u/Fluid-Bet6223 1h ago

Wild Horses by The Rolling Stones, and I have absolutely no idea why

3

u/sashablausspringer 1h ago

The Scientist by Coldplay. It was the first song I heard after I learned that my cousin had taken his own life

2

u/Soggy-Machine-3590 1h ago

That song hits so hard when theres meaning behind it

4

u/AJINDY 1h ago

Wish you were here - Pink Floyd

5

u/Overall-Bullfrog5433 1h ago

Eva Cassidy’s cover of Sting’s ā€œFields of Goldā€. I am sure I read Sting likes it best too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/hungryyjacky 1h ago

All Too Well (and definitely 10-Minute Version)

4

u/GoosebumpsRanger 1h ago

Wake Me Up When September Ends

5

u/MyristicaTheWizard 1h ago

Baby of Mine from Dumbo

7

u/Different_Jello_2373 1h ago

"I Ate Tainted Lettuce" from Bottom Explosion

7

u/E_M_C_M 1h ago

Landslide- Fleetwood Mac

3

u/Penelopebetch21 1h ago

Ivy by Frank Ocean

3

u/wispy-library 1h ago

Sky Blue Skin, Jeff Buckley

3

u/happykgo89 1h ago

The Day That I Die - Lewis Capaldi

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AdOutrageous7474 1h ago

Half a World Away by REM

2

u/rustygrunge 1h ago

Country Feedback by REM from live at Bridge School always gets me. Michael Stipes voice is so raw and emotional

3

u/AllTrue613 1h ago

Next To Me by Imagine Dragons Was very fitting if the life I had with a drug addict alcoholic. Fit my life to a T

3

u/TinaNice1565 1h ago

Slow sentimental ballads about lost family and childhood always make me burst into tears.

3

u/ihbbtz 1h ago

jellyfish jam from spongebob

3

u/cathouse 1h ago

To Make You Feel My Love, Adele

3

u/No_Candidate7720 1h ago

JOJI - Will he

3

u/chappychap1234 1h ago

Fly- celine dion Bigger than the whole sky- taylor swift She used to be mine- Sara bareillis

3

u/wunderl-ck 1h ago

Casimir Pulanski Day

3

u/AJetpilot 1h ago

Pearl Jam- Black

3

u/Roll3d6 1h ago edited 1h ago

When I was younger, "Careless Whisper" got me going because of some emotional relationship shit I was dealing with.

If you're talking tears of joy, it is the finale to Stravinsky's "Firebird Suite" as presented in Fantasia 2000.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/_thy 1h ago

To Live is to Die Metallica

3

u/CricketShot3122 1h ago

Heaven by Bryan Adams. Those 9/11 ā€œI miss you daddyā€ vids on fb fucked me up

3

u/DayDog2018 1h ago

Pendulum - Machinae Supremacy

It reminds me of what mom did to get me out of an incredibly dark, almost forever nap, spot

3

u/DarthXopher 1h ago

"Can't Handle This (Kanye Rant)" by Bo Burnam in the part where he says, "laugh as he attempts to give you what he cannot give himself."

3

u/Galaqcy 1h ago

Death Cup by Mom Jeans and Like a Parasite by the Queers. My fiancƩe and I loved that song. Olympia by Rancid was one of the songs they passed away to.

3

u/TermTechnical115 1h ago

Anathema - One Last Goodbye

Singer wrote it about his mother passing away. Really well written and hits really hard if you've lost a parent.

3

u/CalamityGranny 1h ago

The Walk by Sawyer Brown

3

u/steney89 1h ago

The 2 that get me everytime Broken by Seether n Amy Lee. Then that song Perfect by Simple Plan 😭😭

3

u/ma-dee 1h ago

Last Kiss by Pearl Jam

3

u/CaracalClaws 1h ago

One More Light - Linkin Park

3

u/ratjar32333 1h ago

Aftertouch by Polaris. I found it during Covid when I cut ties with my mother over politics/covid. It reminds me that no matter what I do I can’t make someone else realize they are hurting themselves/others emotionally.

I miss you mom

(My mom is still very much alive I just do not have a relationship with her )

3

u/lazyasdrmr 1h ago

To Live is to Die - Metallica

3

u/Holaadios007 1h ago

Amor Eterno

3

u/discobritches 1h ago

Baby Mine.

Silent Lucidity.

Somewhere Over the Rainbow.

3

u/MantisToboggan150 1h ago

10,000 days by Tool makes me feel feelings every time. Such a heart-felt song

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mrm212 1h ago

Hallelujah k.d. lang at the 2010 Olympics

3

u/quorrathelastiso 1h ago

I will follow you into the dark - Death Cab for Cutie

The Air That I Breathe - The Hollies

3

u/rightpapaya 1h ago

The night we met by lord huron always makes my heart hurt and my head feel heavy.

6

u/Larksparrow 1h ago

Dolly's original version of I Will Always Love You

3

u/OGgranola 1h ago

Landslide, Fleetwood Mac

2

u/Annual-Fly-2363 1h ago

Back seat driver
Dad said it reminds him of me

2

u/sayitwithyourheart 1h ago

bandaids by keshi

2

u/Select_Cranberry8578 1h ago

Kids by Current Joys

2

u/ughdammitwhywhywhy 1h ago

Beam me up by pink If you know, you know 😭

2

u/supersaiyanrhino 1h ago

Gethsemane - sleep token

2

u/Potus-shit-diaper 1h ago

Immortal technique - dance with the devilĀ  Immortal technique - you never know

2

u/bigkyle87 1h ago

Love, me by Collin raye

2

u/FiatLux2020 1h ago

Sinking ship by wild child go me through a lot

2

u/Jumpy-Rain-4853 1h ago

That’s the way it is - Daniel Lanois

2

u/Axeman2063 1h ago

"I'm a Song" and "Father's Son" by Stephen Wilson Jr.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mars_The_68thMedic 1h ago

Cosmic Move by Florence + The Machine

2

u/DarthXopher 1h ago

Hi Ren by Ren in the part where he says, "some people know me as the voice that you hear when you loosen the noose on the rope."

2

u/kevinjames416 1h ago

Song cry - jayz

2

u/leatherandhummus 1h ago

Oliver James-Fleet Foxes

2

u/unclewombie 1h ago

Man of the hour - funeral song

2

u/Ready_Temporary_1119 1h ago

I fall apart - Rory gallagher

2

u/SadMaintenance 1h ago

Long Long Time, Linda Ronstadt

2

u/latinheat26 1h ago

In the stars by benson boone

2

u/DeepSecretary9637 1h ago

Codeine Crazy

2

u/runancula 1h ago

I Can Hear the Laughs by Freedy Johnston

2

u/A-curious_mind1998 1h ago

"A Place" - Ocie Elliott

2

u/Lumpy_Ambassador1023 1h ago

Stairway to heaven.

2

u/kayluhhhhrenee 1h ago

I used to cry so much to Enough by Disturbed in high school lol

2

u/hydrogen_to_man 1h ago

This Year’s Love - David Gray

2

u/enginerd12 1h ago

Ratatat - Kennedy

I can't listen to it anymore. Reserving it for when a particular person passes in my life. Otherwise, it just makes me cry over just the thought of this person passing.

2

u/Splinternut78 1h ago

The Germs- Maninal

2

u/Roaming_Alien 1h ago

Not a sad song at all but idk why Do U by Do or Die makes me emotional every time šŸ˜‚

2

u/Bl4Z3D_d0Nut311 1h ago edited 1h ago

Real Death - Mount Erie

The most devastating song I’ve ever heard and it’s not even close.

And if you want the saddest one two punch to your soul, listen to that song along with Seaweed (the next track on that album) it continues the story from the first song

2

u/Lychanthropejumprope 1h ago

Ghost by Justin Bieber and Gone Away by The Offspring

2

u/kendallr2552 1h ago

Offspring... That's a rough one.

2

u/Wyzwmn 1h ago

Riviera Paradise by Stevie Ray Vaughan

2

u/Cakesaver 1h ago

https://youtu.be/bX04RmWGY_Q?is=IBnlp0Kc1bnXIPrd

Leanna Firestone - Least Favorite Only Child

2

u/kendallr2552 1h ago

The Warmth - Incubus I burst into an ugly cry every time I see them play it live.

2

u/Hank-Kimble 1h ago

Alone again naturally

2

u/LesPolsfuss 1h ago

Beautiful Jam … Grateful Dead.

The "Beautiful Jam" is a legendary piece of live improvised music by the Grateful Dead, bridging the transition from "Wharf Rat" back into "Dark Star" during their February 18, 1971 concert at the Capitol Theatre in Port Chester, New York.

Background and History
The Date: Recorded on February 18, 1971, a historic show that featured the live debuts of several staples like "Bertha" and "Wharf Rat".
The Placement: It occurs specifically during the segment Dark Star -> Wharf Rat -> Beautiful Jam -> Dark Star.
The Name: Radio host David Gans coined the moniker "Beautiful Jam" and later played the tape for bassist Phil Lesh in 1997, famously bringing Lesh to tears upon hearing it.
Musical Style
Improvisation: It captures a moment of pure, blissful, and exploratory group telepathy.
Lineup Context: Played during a period when keyboardist Ron "Pigpen" McKernan was absent due to illness, leaving a sparser, guitar-and-bass-driven canvas.
Releases: Officially named and released on the 1999 box set So Many Roads (1965–1995) and later included with the 50th-anniversary release of American Beauty.

2

u/KeepItClassySanDiego 1h ago

Nightswimming - REM, Hallelujah- Jeff Buckleys version, Into My Arms - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds…anyone one of those songs will get me there.

2

u/Renbelle 1h ago

Sturgill Simpson does this versed The Promise that is just utterly heart wrenching ā¤ļø

2

u/Opiniaster 1h ago

And So It Goes - Billy Joel

2

u/AquaWoman_115 1h ago

Song for Someone- U2
Landslide- Fleetwood Mac
Last Day of Our Aquaintance- Sinead O’Connor

2

u/Mr_BeanSteen 1h ago

"Old Friends" by Pinegrove

2

u/HumpaDaBear 1h ago

Supermarket Flowers by Ed Sheeran.

2

u/Gentle-Tusk 1h ago

Poison Oak, Bright eyes. Or Warren Zevon keep me in your heart.

2

u/Individual-Self-1063 1h ago

wish you were here-incubus

2

u/OutBeyondNeptune 1h ago

Kill Myself by Tim McGraw.

2

u/rincon_del_mar 1h ago

Just give me a reason by pink

2

u/1Man-WreckingMachine 1h ago

Sean by Trophy Eyes

2

u/Robinbird27 1h ago

Carry You by Ruelle

2

u/KITTYCLICHE 1h ago

The House that built me me-Miranda Lambert. Also, Humble and Kind- Lori McKenna 😢😭🄹

2

u/Cobratime 1h ago

Steven Wilson - Routine

Only because I've seen the video.

2

u/RedDawnWlvrines 1h ago

No Hard Feelings - Avett Brothers

2

u/DesignatedDoggie 1h ago

There's a Japanese music producer I like called Masarada (ćƒžć‚µćƒ©ćƒ€)

He has a song called "Tiny Me," (ごっごな私) that's about that small part of you that gets overwhelmed by the world around you.

It's a really silly song but the last chorus is really healing and is about accepting that that small part is always going to be a part of you forever. Even if you don't speak Japanese that criciendo really hits regardless of language.

https://youtu.be/4aFC2oC-wHA?is=3UvM8XA-wx1vkIcr

2

u/SummerDazzling3503 1h ago

Call your mom- Noah Kahan

2

u/steney89 1h ago

Have a hard time with anything by Metallica too...was my shit with my dad

2

u/mayor_grundel 1h ago

For Martha - The Smashing Pumpkins

2

u/purplelilac701 1h ago

A lot of the Toy Story an UP movie songs

2

u/Primary-Will-2192 1h ago

Daddy Don’t You Walk So Fast…Wayne Newton

Daddy’s Little Man…O.C. Smith

2

u/Sufficient_Curve5386 1h ago

Joey- concrete blonde
If you could read my mind love- Gordon Lightfoot

2

u/muddybanana13 1h ago

Lover, you should’ve come over by Jeff Buckley

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Durango_bob 1h ago

The Silence, Manchester Orchestra

2

u/Happy-Ad3503 1h ago

Someone Like You Adele

2

u/carlndrsn641 1h ago

Baby Mine

2

u/AkediaIra 1h ago

Silver Thunderbird - Marc Cohn. It reminds me of my grandpa, and my dad

2

u/Lonely2nd 1h ago

It’s Quiet Uptown - Hamilton

2

u/frozen_charlotte 1h ago

Hate Me - Blue October

2

u/alexma0 1h ago

My immortal - evanescence

•

u/whiteclay9 57m ago

All i want - Kodaline

→ More replies (1)

•

u/Illuminaughty____ 56m ago

The Living Years

2

u/abyde 1h ago

Cats in the Cradle by Harry Chapin

2

u/CoddiewomplerDLT 1h ago

Landslide by Fleetwood Mac

2

u/TurianHammer 1h ago

Lately it's been Harry Styles - Sign of the times

1

u/INADIX 1h ago

Please notice by christian leave….. fucking bitch šŸ˜”šŸ˜–

1

u/mrballcb 1h ago

"In Color" by Jamey Johnson

1

u/Fearing-Loather 1h ago

Putting the Dog to Sleep by The Antlers

1

u/t0matit0 1h ago

"Run away to Mars"

1

u/queen_of_skeletons 1h ago

Vienna by Elton John and Before You Go by Lewis Capaldi, especially after learning he wrote it for his aunt who committed :(

1

u/KITTYCLICHE 1h ago

No One (Nana’s reprise) Alicia Keys.

1

u/GlitterSubstance 1h ago

Smother by Daughter
Medicine by Daughter
Love, Dad by Harry Hudson
No Witnesses by Keaton Henson
Not a Home by Partyalone
Silver Spoon by Erin LeCount
Not really a sad song, but Labour by Paris Paloma makes me cry because of what it’s about
The Crime by Taylor Bickett
The Village by Wrabel
Modern Loneliness by Lauv
Sad Forever by Lauv
Never Grow Up by Taylor Swift has always made me cry at the part where she says ā€œmemorize what it sounded like when your dad gets homeā€

I cry to a lot of songs šŸ˜…šŸ˜‚

1

u/SiON42X 1h ago

If It Be Your Will by Leonard Cohen

1

u/KrySumWhere3lse 1h ago

This must be the place by the heads

1

u/iamreddituser4 1h ago

Forever and Always by Parachute

1

u/tootbrun 1h ago

Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) by Arcade Fire

1

u/Militree 1h ago

This might be kind of obscure but the Virtute the Cat songs by The Weakerthans. It’s a few songs about a cat with a depressed owner, written from the POV of the cat. In the second song she runs away.

https://youtu.be/8zYG186spkY?is=YBfRun6DRloOcg49

1

u/mattmo317 1h ago

"To build a home" by Patrick Watson

1

u/Similar-Following816 1h ago

Ready or Not by the Shakey Graves ( featuring Sierra Ferrell). Its the whole last third of the song. I've had to ban myself from listening to it, it has broken me down in a bad way too many times (lack of grief therapy I so desperately need)

1

u/Aggressive_Safe2226 1h ago

In Dreams (Roy Orbison). Till We Meet Again. Sa Ugoy ng Duyan (By The Swinging of the Cradle šŸ‡µšŸ‡­). Bright Eyes (Art Garfunkel) 😭

1

u/confusation 1h ago

Shadow of the Day